How to Pick the Right Bug Bounty Programs: Lessons from the Trenches
Choosing your first bug bounty programs is arguably the most critical decision in your hunting journey. It can make or break your initial experience, and I learned this the hard way by wasting months on poorly managed or overly restrictive programs. Let me share the lessons I’ve picked up to help you hit the ground running.
Step 1: Align with Your Skills and Interests
Start with what you know. If you’re comfortable with web applications, focus on programs with large scopes — more in-scope domains and IP ranges mean more opportunities to find vulnerabilities.
When I started, I stuck to web apps because they aligned with my skill set. Over time, I ventured into:
- Mobile apps: Testing APIs and app logic.
- Software testing: Diving into binaries and local apps.
- Reverse engineering: Using tools like Ghidra (RIP IDA Pro, which was fantastic but pricey).
Tip: Progression should be natural. Begin with your strengths and branch out as you gain confidence.
Step 2: Prioritize Platform-Managed Programs
Look for programs marked as “Managed by HackerOne” or “Managed by Bugcrowd”. Here’s why:
- Professional Triagers: These programs have experienced security analysts reviewing your submissions, reducing the chance of frustrating debates over the validity of your findings.
- Faster Response Times: Platform-managed programs often handle reports more efficiently than company-managed ones.
Why This Matters
I once reported a critical API vulnerability to a company-managed program. Their internal team dismissed it as “not exploitable.” It took me three days to build a proof-of-concept (PoC) to prove them wrong. If this had been a platform-managed program, the issue would have been triaged and resolved within hours.
Step 3: Recognize Red Flags in Scopes
Not all programs are created equal. To save time and avoid frustration, steer clear of:
- Tiny Scopes: Programs with only one or two domains or applications.
- Vague Scope Definitions: Phrases like “everything except what’s not allowed” signal poor management.
- Inactive Programs: Check program stats for payout history; avoid programs with no recent activity.
- Lengthy Out-of-Scope Lists: Programs with excessive exclusions but minimal in-scope targets are often unproductive.
- Slow Response Times: Programs that take weeks or months to respond to submissions can kill your motivation.
Step 4: Look for Positive Indicators
Instead, focus on programs with:
- Clear, Detailed Scopes: A well-defined scope shows that the company values its bug bounty program and respects hunters’ time.
- Regular Scope Updates: Frequent updates suggest an active program with new opportunities.
- Good Average Response Times: A fast triage team keeps the process smooth and rewarding.
- Recent Bounty Payments: Programs paying bounties consistently demonstrate their seriousness.
- Transparent Severity Guidelines: Clear rules help you gauge the potential value of your findings.
Step 5: Use Tools to Maximize Efficiency
Invest time in automation and reconnaissance tools like:
- ReNgine: To maintain detailed maps of program scopes for rapid action on updates.
- Nuclei: For automating vulnerability scans with customizable templates.
- Custom Scripts: To speed up repetitive tasks like endpoint discovery and parameter fuzzing.
Automation not only saves time but also gives you a competitive edge, especially when scopes expand or change.
Final Thoughts
Picking the right programs early on is about aligning with your skills, avoiding pitfalls, and maximizing opportunities. Don’t waste time on programs that don’t respect hunters or have overly restrictive policies. Start with platform-managed programs and focus on building a solid reputation.
As you gain experience, you’ll be able to tackle larger scopes, diversify your skills, and unlock more lucrative opportunities. Remember, bug bounty hunting is a marathon, not a sprint — plan strategically, execute effectively, and enjoy the rewards of your efforts.
Making Scope Changes Work for You in Bug Bounty Hunting
Here’s a lesser-discussed secret in bug bounty hunting: scope changes are golden opportunities. When a program updates its scope to include new domains, IPs, or features, it’s like fresh snow on a mountain — untouched and full of potential.
Why Scope Changes Are Your Best Friend
1. New Scope, New Bugs
When scope changes occur, previously untested assets become fair game. Bugs are more likely to exist in these new areas, and being among the first to test them gives you a competitive advantage.
2. Timing Is Everything
Using tools like reNgine, I keep track of active programs and receive instant notifications about scope changes. This way, I can dive into new targets immediately.
3. Edge Cases Are Goldmines
Don’t just skim the scope; read the fine print. Programs that clearly define how they handle edge cases — such as vulnerabilities affecting both in-scope and out-of-scope assets — are worth your time. These edge cases often hide some of the most intriguing bugs, but clarity on handling them is essential before you commit your resources.
The Truth About Big vs. Small Programs
A common misconception is that larger companies automatically have better bug bounty programs. The reality?
- Small Startups: Many small startups have well-managed programs with clear communication and fair rewards.
- Big Corporations: Conversely, some large companies might have poorly managed programs with vague scope definitions or unreasonably long response times.
What Really Matters
The best programs are those that:
- Communicate Clearly: Prompt and professional responses to hunters.
- Offer Fair Bounties: Reward findings based on impact, not just scope size.
- Have Clear Rules: Well-defined scope and severity guidelines.
- Show Active Management: Regularly updated scopes and visible bounty payouts.
Essential Tools of the Trade
Your toolbox is as important as your skills. Here's a breakdown of tools I use:
1. Nuclei
- What It Does: Automates vulnerability scanning with a customizable template system.
- Why It’s Essential: Speeds up initial reconnaissance, especially for large scopes.
2. reNgine
- What It Does: Centralizes reconnaissance, tracking active programs and scope updates.
- Why It’s Essential: Keeps you informed of changes, ensuring you never miss a hunting opportunity.
3. Command Line Tools
- Examples:
nmap
, ffuf
, dirsearch
. - Why They’re Useful: Quick and versatile for discovering endpoints, directories, and services.
4. Cloud Infrastructure (e.g., Azure)
- What It Does: Scales your hunting efforts with automated scans and distributed tasks.
- Why It’s Essential: Ideal for tackling large scopes or performing parallel testing.
Maximizing Your Efficiency
Start with platform-managed programs to build your reputation and hone your skills. As you gain confidence, branch out to less structured programs or ones that require additional effort to navigate.
The key to success is efficiency:
- Use tools to automate repetitive tasks.
- Track programs closely for scope updates.
- Prioritize well-managed programs that value your time.
By focusing on smart strategies and leveraging the right tools, you’ll make the most of every bug bounty opportunity — and stay ahead of the competition.